Four decades after its original release, the charity single Do They Know It’s Christmas? has been re-released with a mix of its previous versions, reigniting debate over its portrayal of Africa and reliance on outdated stereotypes.
First recorded in 1984 by Band Aid in response to the Ethiopian famine, the song raised millions for relief efforts and inspired the historic Live Aid concert in 1985.
However, its lyrics and imagery have faced ongoing criticism for depicting Africa as a land of despair, perpetuating misconceptions about the continent.
Dawit Giorgis, the Ethiopian official who brought attention to the famine, finds the song’s premise offensive, noting that Ethiopia has been a Christian nation for centuries.
Yet, he acknowledges the life-saving impact of Band Aid’s efforts, highlighting the generosity of donors and the dedication of those involved.
Critics, however, argue that lines like “where nothing ever grows; no rain nor rivers flow” ignore Africa’s diversity and resilience, reducing it to a single narrative of suffering.
Recent years have seen increasing scrutiny of Band Aid’s legacy, reflecting broader shifts in conversations about race and representation.
British-Ghanaian rapper Fuse ODG criticized the 2014 version for portraying Africa as devoid of joy and peace, while Ed Sheeran, who contributed to the same recording, has since expressed regret over his involvement.
Both artists highlight how the narrative of the song no longer aligns with evolving global perspectives.
Charities are adapting by focusing on participatory campaigns that center on the voices and experiences of those receiving aid.
Researchers and activists emphasize the importance of abandoning dehumanizing imagery in favor of portraying recipients as agents of their own change.
Kenyan satirist Patrick Gathara observes that the humanitarian sector has moved away from the “victim” narrative, reflecting a growing recognition of Africa’s agency and strength.
Looking ahead, music journalist Christine Ochefu suggests that any modern Band Aid-style project would need to be led by African artists from genres like Afrobeats and amapiano, shedding the outdated savior narrative.
Academic Edward Ademolu proposes a complete reimagining, calling for a collaborative effort where Africa is not merely a subject but a co-author of its own story.
As Band Aid marks its 40th anniversary, its financial impact remains undeniable, having raised millions for countries like Ethiopia and Sudan.
However, its cultural legacy faces increasing scrutiny, with many advocating for a new approach that celebrates Africa’s vibrancy and complexity while addressing its challenges with dignity and respect.
Also read: Sophie Ellis-Bextor To Host And Perform At BBC One’s New Year Disco
