Clint Eastwood’s rise to international fame began with his unforgettable role as a brooding gunslinger in Sergio Leone’s A Fistful of Dollars—but he wasn’t the director’s first choice for the part. In a revealing 1977 interview with the BBC, the legendary Italian director confessed that he initially wanted another Hollywood star for the iconic role that would change Eastwood’s career forever.
Picture this: a mysterious stranger, draped in a dusty poncho, struts down a deserted street in a sun-scorched town. He instructs the coffin-maker to “get three coffins ready” before dispatching a group of menacing thugs. After the gunfire, he calmly quips, “My mistake. Four coffins.” This is one of the most iconic scenes in A Fistful of Dollars (1964), solidifying Eastwood’s place in film history.
However, the role of the Man with No Name almost went to James Coburn (The Magnificent Seven, The Great Escape). In an interview, Leone explained, “I really wanted James Coburn, but he was too expensive.” Coburn’s price tag? $25,000, a far cry from Eastwood’s more affordable $15,000 (equivalent to £116,000 today).
At the time, Eastwood was already a familiar face thanks to his role in the TV series Rawhide. He wasn’t immediately drawn to the low-budget European film, but he saw potential in Leone’s fresh take on the Western genre. “I liked A Fistful of Dollars, and I felt that maybe a European approach would give the Western new flavor,” Eastwood reflected in the BBC interview.
Leone wasn’t impressed by Eastwood’s acting in Rawhide, but he was captivated by the actor’s physical presence, describing Eastwood’s movements as “indolent” and likening him to a cat. Despite mixed feelings about the casting, the collaboration between Eastwood and Leone was a game-changer.
A Fistful of Dollars, loosely based on Akira Kurosawa’s samurai film Yojimbo, was unlike any Western that had come before. It followed Eastwood’s morally ambiguous “Joe,” a drifter who stirs up a gang war in a Mexican border town for his own profit. This gritty, violent, and stylish take on the Western turned heads in the film industry.
“It was an Italian-German-Spanish co-production of a remake of a Japanese film in the plains of Spain,” Eastwood humorously recalled, shedding light on the international nature of the project. With language barriers on set, the actors would often speak in their native tongues, and dialogue was later dubbed into Italian and English for different audiences.
When the film premiered in Italy in 1964, it wasn’t exactly a critical darling. In fact, Italian critics panned the film, and similar negative reviews followed in other countries. UK critic Philip French dismissed it as “calculated sadism,” while The New York Times called it a synthetic Western full of clichés. The US release was delayed until 1967 due to legal concerns from Kurosawa, who accused Leone of plagiarizing Yojimbo.
Despite the initial backlash, A Fistful of Dollars became a worldwide hit and gave birth to the “Spaghetti Western” genre, an irreverent twist on the traditional Western. This new genre focused on anti-heroes, moral ambiguity, and gritty realism. Eastwood’s Joe, with his rugged charm and ruthless efficiency, became the archetype for the Spaghetti Western hero.
The film also introduced moviegoers to the unmistakable style of Leone. His wide shots, tense close-ups, and haunting scores by composer Ennio Morricone became trademarks of the genre. Leone once described his films as “basically silent films” where dialogue was merely an accessory, a style that influenced directors like Quentin Tarantino and Robert Rodriguez.
As A Fistful of Dollars grew in stature, so did Eastwood’s star. His portrayal of the silent, stoic gunslinger resonated with audiences worldwide, catapulting him to film stardom and eventually leading to even greater success in Hollywood. For Eastwood, this low-budget Western turned out to be the role of a lifetime, one that would cement his legacy in the annals of cinema history.
Also read: Emily Maitlis Reflects On Prince Andrew Interview
