The Victorian Society’s South Yorkshire group has accused Sheffield City Council of delaying conservation protections for Castlegate’s historic buildings for five years.
The charity claims the lack of action has put several key sites at “increased risk.”
Nigel Slack, the group’s regional chair, highlighted the recent loss of three historic buildings: the Market Tavern on Exchange Street, the Old Coroner’s Court on Nursery Street, and the former Wiley & Co building on Haymarket.
He argued that designating Castlegate as a conservation area would provide much-needed legal protections.
The group opposed the council’s suggestion to merge Castlegate into the existing city centre conservation area, saying it would dilute protections.
“Castlegate is not simply an add-on to the city centre,” Slack insisted, emphasizing its unique architectural heritage.
In response, Councillor Ben Miskell, head of the council’s transport, regeneration, and climate policy committee, announced that consultants were hired last week to review Sheffield’s conservation areas, including Castlegate.
He confirmed recommendations would be made by March 2025, with a final decision expected by summer 2025.
Miskell expressed optimism about Castlegate’s future, citing plans for a new park and showcasing the city’s castle remains.
He added that funding from the government and Historic England would support efforts to reassess Sheffield’s conservation areas.
Despite the council’s assurances, heritage advocates continue to push for immediate conservation protections to preserve Castlegate’s historic character.
Also read: Mufasa: The Lion King Falls Short As A Prequel
